Blog 
 
 Your Comments 
ELECTION REFLECTION
Jerry Ballard (Guest), Mon 9 Aug, 12:13am
A BUDGET ODYSSEY
KARMA MGTOW (Guest), Wed 7 Jul, 1:02am
is the end of poverty possible?
Steve Jones, Sat 15 May, 8:34pm
 
 Older Posts 
CAMPAIGNING IN LUTON SOUTH
Ungrateful , untrustworthy Africa
I love the BBC
Justice, Rights and Human Wrongs (Part 1)
Brainwashing is sexy
The Politics of Integrity
ETHICALLY SOURCED FRUIT
Is Loyalty a Virtue?
Robertson's Siloam
Meeting with the Archbishop of Sudan a Great Success
Amy Orr Ewing: Changing times in our culture – the challenge of the Millennials
Banks must rediscover values for their own survival.
Give to Caesar what is Caesars: Taxation and the Developing World
CSM at Labour Conference Part III
CSM at Labour Conference Part II
CSM at Labour Conference Part I
Francoise PJ
Latest Book Review
is the end of poverty possible?
Final Thoughts...
My final two meetings!
Day Four
Day Three At CSM
One body with many parts
On the campaign trail
 'Events, dear boy, events'
The start of a week at CSM
THE BIG QUESTIONS
Losing Sight of the Big Picture
JESUS AND THE BNP
Northern Ireland
RSS Feed for latest articles
 

CSM is Blogging.

In this section of the site, we'd like to highlight blogs from some of those involved in CSM.  You'll find details of our Director, Andy Flannagan's blog and others too.


You can also check out our front page for latest Tweets and Twitters.

The Power of Yes and No

 
Last night I went to see David Hare’s play “The power of Yes” at the National Theatre. It is an incredible play with a stellar cast, but what is truly jaw-dropping about it is its ambition. I know many folks involved in theatre whose greatest desire is for performances to entertain, move and educate in equal measure. But surely there has never been a play that has so audaciously attempted to take its audience from a place of mere tabloid understanding of the world economic system to the details of securitised credit derivatives and beyond in just 98 minutes!
 
The amazing thing was that it managed it. I brought a friend to whom the world of “dicing and slicing” was all new, and on the way home we had an informed conversation about finance that would simply not have been possible 3 hours earlier.
 
The play follows David Hare the playwright as he interviews the major players to get to the bottom of how the crisis could have occurred. Most of time we were left to scribble our own abhorrence on our mental notepads as revelation after revelation played out mostly without a hint of regret. There is however impressive nuance and understanding in the search for scapegoats,(except in the case of Fred Goodwin, the ex-chair of RBS.)
 
There is great support for CSM’s campaign to see retail and casino banking separated in the content of the play. In fact if I had been standing at the exit with a clipboard asking people to sign up, I can’t see how they wouldn’t have, given the evidence they were presented with.
 
The most profound parts of the play are when the very nature of the banking industry is called into question. The “take home moment” occurs when David Hare’s “lecturer” reminds him that the word credit comes from the root credo – to believe. Credit is not just a financial transaction. Credit is only truly credit and only serves the common good, when it is built on trust. The relationship between lender and borrower is all important. Without that relationship, trust and credo, we are left merely with numbers on a balance sheet. And you don’t need me to explain how the gradual separation of lender and borrower caused the greatest economic crisis of all time.
 
So it was timely today when I received a piece of work being done on the influence of Christians on the formation of friendly societies, building societies, mutuals, and co-operatives. These were and are organisations predicated on the true meaning of credit. It was inspiring to read how these organisations were set up to help working people buy houses, secure sick pay, and receive pensions. There was a sense of the common good. How different things are now. But the pendulum is swinging. We must take up the challenge of explaining to a new generation that “it wasn’t always like this” – that money wasn’t always a private thing, separate from character and community, and that a shared life on this planet involves sharing the wonderful resources it provides.
 
David Hare’s play leaves one in no doubt that the playground of high finance has been an ethics-free zone, where pursuit of profit became the only driving force rather than any sense of the common good. Dissenting voices were scorned and condemned as dinosaurs from a bygone age. I was left thinking that there is in fact an incredible power in the word “yes”, and in the momentum of “progress”. It was impossible for anyone to swim against the prevailing tide. It is a stark reminder that at times we are called to the less popular place. The place where we must say, “No.”

 


Andy Flannagan, 24/08/2010


0 Comments  |  Permalink

A BUDGET ODYSSEY

Has anyone noticed the elephant in the budget room?

Forget the detail for a moment (though it is truly shocking.) It’s the big picture that we should be focusing on. The raison d’etre – the grand sweep. The level of honesty that explicitly stated that what we are primarily doing with the budget now is trying to appease the markets was truly disturbing.


Yes I understand the short-term importance of our credit rating etc, but in the midst of constant short-termism we are not noticing that our noble straining most resembles a hamster in a wheel, expending energy purely for someone else’s entertainment.


Have our memories become so short? We were handed a once in a generation opportunity to realign the power axis between democracy and capitalism, and it looks like we have failed. What was exposed during the credit crunch (more accurately a debt crisis) was the myth of self-regulation, and the screaming need for oversight.#


An analogy from science fiction seems most appropriate. A common theme of many futuristic tales is that humanity builds computers and robots to do their dirty work. This goes swimmingly for some time until classically the machines rebel, subjugating humanity in the process. The programmed amoral lunatics take over the asylum. Does any of this sound familiar? Our hooverbot was handy in the short-term, but now has a veto over our household budget. That’s how insane it all is.


So this is not solely a debate about left and right (even though that is vitally important in terms of specific policy). We will win a much broader groundswell of people to our cause if we articulate this battle in terms of restoring democracy to its rightful place. It isn’t perfect, but at least it is accountable. Let the battle between capitalism and democracy be observed. For only then can it be joined.


Andy Flannagan, 24/06/2010


2 Comments  |  Permalink

ELECTION REFLECTION

 

Now that the dust has settled on the General Election of 2010 (or what many were calling the “first general election of 2010!), it is a good time to take stock and share some of the stories of the campaign.


CSM has never been so involved in a campaign as in this one, both during the weeks of the short campaign, and the preparatory work before it. Since last summer CSM members had been linking up PPCs and sitting MPs with church members and leaders across the country through our marginals project. We wrote an official Labour booklet on interacting with faith groups for all candidates, and ran training sessions at party conference. We helped co-ordinate election strategy with relation to Christians in particular, affording many opportunities to reiterate our policy objectives.


Through Paul Burgin’s work as campaigns co-ordinator, CSM members and branches were directed to specific campaigning days in various parts of the country to support CSM candidates. Many local parties reported their surprise at the level of support that Christians seemed to be able to draw on. This was no better exemplified than in Luton South, where the support of many young Christians especially was vital to the incredible campaign that reversed the picture of huge losses in the south-east. From Bromsgrove to Gosport, results were bucking regional trends because many CSM members and other local Christians got involved.


The exciting thing I discovered as I went around the country was the following. Many CSM members were campaigning for the first time – and they loved it. People who had promised to come to a constituency for just one day found that they got “the bug” and ended up going back for many days. I think people were grasping the incredible opportunities that campaigning affords: one – to meet real people and hear their joys and struggles, two – to bond with local Labour party members in a way that only a shared task allows, and three – to put into words and practice what has often just been a theory of how Christians bring the kingdom into politics.


I was so proud to see the impact of groups of CSM members on various local parties. “They’re so enthusiastic”, “They’re a breath of fresh air”, “They’re so positive” were the sort of things you were hearing. Add to this the huge numbers of voters that CSM members were able to reach through interacting with churches, through speaking or hustings and you start to see why the party is waking up to what is possible.


In the spirit of that famous Battersea Dog’s home advert, let’s remember that politics is for life, not just for elections, and build on the momentum that has been achieved. Let’s not “despise the day of small beginnings”, as what starts out as a coffee, or something stronger, sharing passion with a local party member, may well lead to you being a candidate in 5 years time.


Also, let’s soberly reflect on the places where some more help from CSM members may well have made all the difference. I’m thinking in particular of Warrington South, which so easily could have gone the way of CSM member Nick Bent. I honestly believe a few more foot soldiers would have tipped the scales just enough. The people who put their heads above the parapet and take on the arduous role of being a candidate, with the long hours and constant media attention really need our practical and prayerful support. Let’s become a movement that is sensitive to places of need and able to respond, working sacrificially for our brothers and sisters. Those who got involved this time have testified that there is nothing like it.


We obviously haven’t yet had a chance to compile all the stories from the council elections as well as the parliamentary elections, so please do email us with your own reflections, and what we should be learning.


So here we are. A new political season - but one which is already ripe with opportunity for CSM. Ears are open to hear that were never listening before. I have never been more excited about my role here. We are genuinely contributing to the debate on the future of politics on the left through many conversations and hustings preparation. Please make your voice heard on the CSM forum.


And a final word of tribute to our dear friend Stephen Timms, who in his role as vice-chair for faith in the party has done an incredible job. He is also a ceaseless support to CSM. We are so glad that he has made a recovery and now returned to work, but our prayers continue to be with him after what was a shocking incident. His election result bears testimony to his hard work and commitment to his constituency. As someone said to me the other day, you don’t win the largest majority in the House of Commons without some favour on you. It is obvious that Stephen carries a favour that is not merely electoral, and we celebrate that too.


Andy Flannagan, 11/06/2010


3 Comments  |  Permalink

LOOKING FOR A LEADER


I fear the outbreak of Cleggmania that has occurred in the last few days says more about the state of the UK than any measure of GDP or inflation. A couple of years ago I stated the fear that reality TV-style voting would be so deeply embedded in the public consciousness that it would have a profound impact on the next election. I think we are seeing it. In our sofa-bound, remote-controlling consumerist state we are conditioned to voting for who most entertains us, or whose story we most identify with. Policy is a mere sideshow. It’s a Big Brother-esque desire to vote people out because “we’re bored of looking at this lot now, we want some new folks to look at”. In many ways, politics has become the soap opera opiate of the middle classes, numbing our senses from the reality of daily life by providing easy targets to blame for every ill. We outsource our own responsibility as citizens and communities, able to point the finger at those who are obviously morally weaker than us.


2007 provided the perfect example of this. Toward the end of Tony Blair’s time in office, cries were going up from all quarters, “We don’t want an actor who will deceive us. Just give us someone who will roll up their sleeves and get the job done.” “No more spin”. Cue Gordon Brown’s appearance, and a tumultuous reception, followed by an acclaimed first 100 days. But after the novelty of the new man had worn off, these same people could be heard crying, “Can we have Tony back please?” “He made us feel good, and tickled our tummies”. “That’s really what we want – a performer to make us feel everything’s okay.”

That’s what we really really want sadly – someone with the X-factor.


But I don’t think it’s what we need. The last few days’ desperate straining toward someone who most of the country know nothing about has certainly energised the election and taken things in a direction which I am personally happy about, but I fear it does expose a gaping hole in our souls. As human beings created in the image of God, I believe we all have an innate desire to connect with our creator and seek his leadership. This can often gain expression in putting too much expectation on those humans who lead us, whether in church or the wider society, abrogating our individual responsibilities for our own spiritual growth or our communities. Combine this with our need to be entertained, and you get a dangerous mix. This need to be led has been the decisive factor in allowing many 20th century despots to have their way with a people. In this election season, could we refocus on our true leader, who as psalm 145 (the message) says, “never gets voted out of office”, and be encouraged that a large majority of the population are crying out for him too, even if they don’t know it yet.


Andy Flannagan, 20/04/2010


2 Comments  |  Permalink

A Service in St Mary Undercroft: The Chapel In Parliament

Entering the stunningly fanciful chapel was a marvelling experience. I was stepping into a chapter of history; this beautiful architectural masterpiece had originally been completed in all its splendour by King Edward I in 1297 and restored in the 1860 and 1870’s by Edward Barry, who reproduced the early medieval décor, creating a holistic and spiritual house of worship. What struck me the most however was not the exquisite resplendence of the building but instead the congregation. I was surrounded by MP’s and other members of staff from the houses of parliament who had taken time out of their exceptionally hectic schedules on the run up to the election to stop and turn their attentions to Christ.

The sermon declared a message to ‘trust in God’, an important and vital teaching to remember when the future for many individuals is completely unpredictable and their lives are going through significant tests and changes. I talk here not just of the MP’s who face the run-up and results of the election, and the risk of losing their seats to the opposition, or even those who win in the next election as they have the responsibility to serve the people honestly and respectfully. But also of the voters, who have a responsibility to put their faith in the Lord and use their power as citizens to vote for the party who they believe serves the needs of the common good.

The Bible teaches that “God is our refuge and strength, a very present help in trouble.” (Psalm 46:1) It is true that God is our rock and our strength, and as the sermon preached, sometimes it is possible to forget about the power of prayer and the gift of faith and be distracted from the divine will of the Lord. My experience at the service in St Mary Undercroft reminded me that as I battle on in life, in fear of whether or not I will get a job when graduating or get firsts in my exams instead I should be putting my faith in the Lord, as he has a plan, and our responsibility is to “Trust in the LORD with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding. In all thy ways acknowledge him, and he shall direct thy paths.” (Proverbs 3:5-6)

The service made me realise even more so  that being an MP is not by any stretch of the imagination an easy job. As a Christian MP they have the responsibility to live life in the light of Christ, campaigning and working towards social and economical justice. As is represented by the Labour parties promise to make a manifesto that commits to anti-poverty legislations, in response to the Conservative MP who prevented the prohibition of Vulture funds. They work with the intention of bettering their communities whilst constantly being in the public eye, responsible for their every move and yet as I discovered they are still modest and welcoming individuals. They were not intimidating, and nor did they act with any sense of superiority.

Witnessing Christians worshipping in Parliament was an exceptionally thought-provoking experience, a display of how God has worked through these individuals to give them a drive for justice and a passion for working within politics and the public sphere in the light of Christ's teachings.




Eve Parker, 30/03/2010


0 Comments  |  Permalink